The ruling marks a disappointing loss for nine same-sex couples who sued,
demanding health insurance and pension benefits in 1999.
The lawsuit, filed by the Alaska Civil Liberties Union and the American Civil
Liberties Union's Lesbian and Gay Rights Project, represents the interests of
eight lesbian couples in which at least one partner works for the state. The
other couple consists of two gay men, one of whom is an Anchorage city employee.
Lin Davis, a state Labor Department employee, says she has earned the right
to add to her health coverage her partner of 14 years, Maureen Longworth. A
family physician, Longworth said her health-care provider didn't cover
specialist care she required in Seattle several years ago. Since then, she has
paid out-of-pocket expenses of more than $15,000.
The state argued its policy was intended to save money. State health
insurance costs roughly $650 a month per employee. The premium doesn't change if
more people are added, officials have said, but premiums could rise over time if
domestic partners become eligible because the number of claims would go up.
The plaintiffs in the case argued that, like married couples, they intend to
stay together for life and are financially and emotionally responsible for each
other.
The couples were denied benefits because, unlike heterosexual couples, they
don't have the option of getting married, Alaska Civil Liberties Union attorney
Allison Mendel said. Voters in 1998 overwhelmingly approved a constitutional
amendment banning same-sex marriages. Close Window to Return to
TBC Web Site