Egypt: Concerns over detention of
alleged gays
8 June 2001 AI
Index : MDE
12/015/2001
AAmnesty International is gravely concerned about
the ongoing detention of scores of men in Egypt in connection with their sexual
orientation,@ the international organization said
today.
On 6 and 7 June 2001 54
men were brought before the public prosecution in Cairo facing accusations of
Aimmoral behaviour@
and Acontempt of religion@. The men remain in detention since their arrest during the early hours
of 11 May 2001. The following day, they were brought before the public
prosecution where they were issued with a detention order and transferred to
Tora Prison where they continue to be held.
AAmnesty International believes that the majority, if not all, of these
men are detained purely on the grounds of their alleged sexual
orientation,@ the organization said. If people are detained
solely on account of their sexual orientation, Amnesty International would
consider them prisoners of conscience and call for their immediate and
unconditional release.
During
the hearings on 6 and 7 June, the results of forensic medical examinations of
all the detainees were presented. According to Amnesty International=s information, these examinations were primarily conducted in order to
establish whether the men had practised anal sex.
Media coverage of this incident by Egyptian
newspapers has centred on the alleged sexual orientation of the men, portraying
the men in a negative light. In many instances detailed information pertaining
to the men has been published in the press, including names of those arrested,
in some cases their places of work and in one case even the family address of
one of the detainees.
Amnesty
International is also extremely concerned about allegations that the detainees
were tortured or ill-treated during the first days of their detention. There
were also reports of ill- treatment during their arrest. These serious
allegations should be promptly investigated by the Egyptian authorities.
A few days after the arrest
Amnesty International wrote to the Public Prosecutor expressing its concerns and
seeking further clarification about the detention of these men. The organization
has still not received a response.
Background
Amnesty International believes that the
vilification and persecution of persons for their sexuality violate the most
fundamental principles of international human rights law.
The right to freedom from discrimination on the
basis of sex, which includes sexual orientation, is recognized in regional and
international treaties, including the African Charter on Human and Peoples'
Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which
Egypt is a state party.
AContempt of
religion@ is prohibited under Article 98 (f) of the
Egyptian Penal Code and stipulates prison sentences of between six months and
five years. Amnesty International has repeatedly criticized the use of this
vaguely worded article which has been used as the legal pretext for the
imprisonment of prisoners of conscience. Earlier this year writer Salah al-Din
Muhsin was sentenced to three years= imprisonment under Article
98 (f) for "offending religion" in his publications. Charged with violating the
same article, Manal Wahid Mana>i, the alleged leader of a
religious group, and three of her followers were sentenced to prison terms of
between three and five years in September 2000. Amnesty International considers
these men and women to be prisoners of conscience.