Tampa Bay Coalition Eye on GLBT News &
Headlines
by R. Zeke Fread
The Death of Tara Exposes Willow's Darkside
and Fans Outrage
Devoted followers of "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" (BVS) are
left devastated by the producers
of BVS decision to destroy, what many have felt was, a wonderful portrayal
of a loving, honest and natural long term lesbian
relationship. Especially, because such a
relationship are rarely depicted on television programs, as was that of
Tara and Willow's. Our gay
youth, and all viewers of BVS, had for the past three years, the rare opportunity to see two women, openly express their love for
each other as main characters in a television program. A
devoted loving couple, who were trusting,
unselfish and protective of each
other. Reflecting the many lesbian and
gay long term relationships
existing in the real world, but, seldom acknowledged. Our gay youth were able to see this relationship was accepted by viewers, both gay and straight alike, the ever growing popularity of the program.
A message that was desperately
needed for them to hear and see. Albeit, for some it may have been only an hour of drowning out the thoughts of the anti-gay messages they
are exposed daily. BVS's storyline of an openly gay
loving relationship, had made contributions toward promoting acceptance and tolerance, that could never be measured by
ratings alone.
They say all good things must come to an end, whether this
is be true or not. The fans of BVS are not the
least bit accepting of the end of Tara and Willow's long term relationship. It is not because, they don't believe good things
do come to an end. It is the how producers choose to end
Tara's and Willow's relationship has them disgusted and
outraged. Showing the couple dressing in their bedroom, suggesting they
may have just made love. Tara is
shot and killed by a stray bullet, that came through a window she had just
looked out of. Willow seeing this happen right before
her eyes, becomes crazed, tracks down Tara's murder, tortures and murders him, attempts to kill his associates, two of her
friends and attempts to end her pain by
destroying the world. Fans feel strongly this was
not a fitting end for Tara and Willows relationship.
They have taken to the net to vent their anger. This may
sound like, it's only a television show, what's the big deal. Well, BVS fans say the big deal is, once again television producers
are falling back on the Dead/Evil Lesbian Cliché. This
being introducing gay characters, only to kill them off or turn them in to villains. In this
case, BVS's producers have choose
to incorporate both, dead and evil. With BVS's fans are understandably
upset about this decision. After watching the storyline
with Tara and Willow go on for three years, you become
very attached to these characters. We all have done the same thing. We, as they, are not delusional and don't forget
these are actors portraying characters in a
television. Never the less, we have developed a
relationship with them. When, in the case of BVS, it
went far beyond the character and viewer relationship. The storyline and the
message that was being sent, acceptance of same-sex
couple, had touched the hearts of many of our gay youth. For three years and one hour a week, they
were able to escape all the negative things
said about them. Then
without warning, this special message they looked so forward to seeing and hearing each week, was abruptly stripped away from them.
And in the worst possible way one can imagine. I was not a fan or viewer of
BVS and sadly had missed the opportunity to see this positive portrayal of
a same-sex couple. However, after reading the many letters I have received on
this matter, I can fell the great disappointment and outrage of that
the loyal fans of BVS are experiencing. I am left asking the same question,
I am sure they are, what possible reason was there for destroying something that
meant so much to so many? Creator of Buffy the Vampire Slayer
posted a message on UPN's Bronze VIP message board, which read in
part, "I knew some people would be angry with me for
destroying the only gay couple on the show, but, the idea that I COULDN'T kill
Tara because she was gay is as offensive to me as the idea that I DID kill her
because she was gay."- Joss Whedon, (www.cise.ufl.edu/~hsiao/media/tv/buffy/bronze/upn/20020522.html).This can only show that he has
absolutely no clue what so ever, as to what BVS fans are actually feeling.
Not one of all the
letters I received, and I receievd a ton, stated the reason they were so
upset and outraged with Joss, the producers or writers, was they couldn't
or did kill Tara because she was gay. What is truly offensive, is the
insensitivity shown to what the throngs of BVS fans and viewers are so
distressed and upset about. It is the refusal to consider,
that their actions destroyed something that was special and meant a great
deal to so many. This excerpt from one letter I received, expresses
the feelings what many others had expressed in their letters also.
"I am not gay. I am a straight married
father in my 30s and I loved Willow and Tara. They meant so much to me. To
watch them destroyed in a very real sense for a weak plot point is beyond
forgivable. In fact I know of many straight Willow/Tara fans that are just
as outraged. They understood what they meant. I can only imagine how this
must feel to that gay, lesbian or questioning teen out there that watched them
and thought "I am ok. And like Willow and Tara I can find true love." Are you
listening Joss, what possible
reason was there for destroying something that meant so
much to so many?
Links:
This site offers FAQ regarding the subject of
:Dead/Evil Lesbian Cliché":
Close Window to Return to TBC
Web Site